The question beneath the AI debate
Most discussions about AI begin with capability: what the model can do, what tasks agents can execute, how much faster work can be completed and how many jobs are exposed. These are important questions. But they start halfway through the problem.
The deeper question is: who becomes more able to act, and who becomes less able to shape what happens?
Philosophically, agency is commonly associated with the capacity to act intentionally; autonomy adds the stronger idea of self-government.1 I use human agency here more practically: the ability to form and revise intentions, exercise judgement, act on them, challenge what influences us and remain responsible for what follows.
A system can expand my options without giving me control over the conditions under which those options are created. It can reduce effort while making me less able to perform the task without it. It can recommend a decision while leaving me formally responsible for an outcome I no longer understand well enough to contest.
Capability is part of agency. It is not the whole of it.